Roundtable–the need to get the story straight

In Delhi last year, Sangam – the Australia India Design Platformhosted a roundtable and forum to share concepts and issues in global craft and design partnerships. There are many opportunities to link artisans to foreign markets through designers. What are new models for this transnational product development? What are the ethical issues and how might we resolve them?

Twenty-nine people looked through the draft standards for ethical labelling in craft products. This included a mix of Australians, Indians, designers, artisans, writers and managers. This group confirmed the standard that the information about producers should be included on the label, though in some cases it might be more appropriate to mention the village or family name, rather the individual artisan.

The most contentious issue was about transparency. Opinion was divided about whether designers should give artisans information about the pricing structure. While most agreed that this was good in principle, there were doubts about whether artisans would understand the kind of mark ups necessary to get product to the shops. This was left as a challenge to see how such information could be presented in a way that was easily understood by those without experience in retail.

Two elements were seen as important to the success of a code. The first is that it should not come at a cost to participants. It should be something that added overall value to the products. And second, that it should be open to verification. To keep costs down, this can be enabled by a system of consumer feedback.

Generally, it was felt that a code was important to increase the value of handmade products by offering consumers more reliable information about their origins.

Glimpses of the Roundtable:

One of the highlights of the Roundtable was an evocative talk by the venerable Indian craft writer Jasleen Dhamija, where she discussed the time-honoured tradition of innovation in Indian craft, and its close association with rites of passage.

For a full report on the Roundtable, go here.

Better World Arts: Friendship calls, from Kaltjiti to Kashmir

  • Carolyn Wilson looking at Kashmiri weavers
  • Kashmiri weavers at work
  • House of Abdul Gani, who advises Better World Arts on Kashmiri weavers
  • Carolyn Wilson visiting Kashmiri weavers
  • Mona Mitkakiki Shepherd Handmade Chainstitched Rug
  • Mrs K Carol Karen Etc Feb 08 Small
  • mrs ken and margaret smiling

Carolyn Wilson has created a remarkable path between Australia and India, finding a way to jointly promote cultural sustainability of Kashmiri artisans and Aboriginal communities. This unusual but successful conjunction arose partly from answering the call of a friend, twice.

Carolyn is the founder of Better World Arts, an organisation that paved new paths for design collaboration, linking Australian Aboriginal painting with Indian weaving. Better World Arts arose from Carolyn’s experience as a tourist in northern India. In 1992, she was meeting up with a friend in the Kashmir. Responding to a telegram, she ventured off to Kashmir, but by the time she arrived, her friend had left. She stayed on and took a houseboat, as seemed the custom. Besides being impressed by the handicrafts, Carolyn was particularly taken with the Kashmiri sense of humour—‘I spent my whole time there laughing.’

It was a life-changing experience. She’d trained as a painter, but now found her own pursuit of art to be a ‘waste of time’. ‘My work wasn’t linked to anything of great significance.’ She decided instead to engage with Indian crafts and started importing rugs. It wasn’t easy. There weren’t many retail outlets in Adelaide and ‘Indian handicraft had been done to death.’

She’d found a Kashmiri family who had a long history of working in handicrafts. The Sidiqs had started the business three generations back to provide outlets for local crafts. So she started sending her designs over to Kashmir to be woven, which proved much more sellable than original works.

Mona Mitkakiki Shepherd Handmade Chainstitched Rug

Mona Mitkakiki Shepherd Handmade Chainstitched Rug

Then in 1996 a friend went to work at Kaltjiti Arts, located at Fregon in the Anangu Pitjantjatjara/Yankunytjatjara Lands (APY Lands) about 200k south of Uluru. She showed her the rugs, and asked if there was potential to work together. It looked promising and they were successful in getting a $5,000 grant from ATSIC to order four designs in two different sizes.

There were problems of translation—of design, not language. The myriad of dots that characterises central Australian Aboriginal painting was problematic for weavers, and she learnt to be quite selective in the paintings she sent for production.

There were plenty of heartaches in the early days. Carolyn had to live mistakes in translation. Sometimes a whole shipment would have the wrong colours. ‘Many a time I would sink in a pile of rugs in despair.’ They used to say sometimes that the dyer was depressed. Colour charts were used to ensure these mistakes did not happen again. Over time quality control over issues like colour improved.

Carolyn likes to keep business informal, based on a handshake. She sends a half-payment with the order, and pays the rest when the work is finished, plus freight and duty. She now tries to travel at least once a year to the Kashmir in order to check quality control and maintain the personal relationships on which her business is based. The best time for orders is between sewing and harvesting. It takes about eight months to have rugs chain-stitched and provides for work for about 60 artisans.

Carolyn is a real pathfinder. As she says, ‘There was no model for me to follow.’ Her business is the result of much trial and error. Looking back over her journey, she acknowledges some missteps: she feels could have been more aggressive in pursuing opportunities, particularly with Aboriginal Arts Centres.

For Better World Artsto succeed, she had to convince people of the value of ‘Aboriginal-derivative products’. ‘When we first started, I had to fight for that.’ She feels this is particularly important for the majority of the communities, who don’t have the same access to the art market. This way combines both cultures. ‘They don’t have a manufacturing culture.’

Now with a great amount of hard work and commitment from staff at Better World Arts, she has opened a space next door to her office in Port Adelaide as a base for Ngura Wiru Wingkiku Arts, which includes the Anangu people who have come down from the desert to live in the city. She is keen to provide work that connects with their culture, and a number of non-financial projects are supported to facilitate this.

But it’s very important that she continues to support the traditional lifestyles of weavers in the Kashmir. ‘We like to support people in their traditional place.’ She is dismayed by the conditions in larger cities like Delhi—‘The sky’s yellow. You wouldn’t want to live there.’

She resists any move towards machine technology. Suppliers have offered her cheaper factor-made goods, but she refused. ‘I said no, I’d prefer to find a way of continuing working with handmade.’ She is currently exploring potential for moving her screen-printing operation to the Kashmir in partnership with the local community.

The model has proven a success. Better World Artshas been feted with many awards. It has even been called ‘the Body Shop of Aboriginal Art in Australia.’ The work continues to sell, even in the current downturn. What’s particularly important to Carolyn is the response of the Aboriginal artists when they seem some of their culture going into someone’s home. ‘Every sale is a little step towards reconciliation.’

The model has been extended to include Peruvian jewellers and Tibetan artisans, and most recently leather workers in West Bengal using the revived Shantiniketan printing process —all producing Aboriginal-derived handmade product for the Australian market.

In the future, she is interested in potential creative dialogue between the Aboriginal painters and the artisans who make the products.

Better World Arts represents a particularly productive design partnership between Australia and India. Aboriginal communities provide the designs and stories that appeal to the Australian market. And the Kashmiri artisans find regular work in providing these products with a handmade quality that enlivens the designs. It’s been a path of great risk and much disappointment. But it’s testament to the value of following your inner values—and responding to a friend in need.

The Best of Both Worlds: International Collaborations in Craft & Design

Saturday 22 October 2011 5-7pm
National Institute of Fashion Technology amphitheatre Green Park, New Delhi, India (see map)

Trent Jansen 'Sign stool' from reused road signs (limited edition)‘The Best of Both Worlds’ considers the increasing number of transnational partnerships being forged between craft and design. How can we combine the free-wheeling possibilities of modern capitalist world with the grounded meaning of cultural traditions?

Typically, a designer from a wealthy Western country seeks to produce something handmade using skills of a traditional artisan. While this does seem to reinforce global inequalities, it is often the best alternative for those seeking to sustain their craft. So how can designers and artisans work together in product development as a fair partnership? How can designers work with artisans in a way that respects their unique contribution? What is the role for Indian designers in these new transnational supply chains?

This forum is part of Sangam: The Australia India Design Platform, which is a three year program of events designed to promote creative design partnerships between Australia and India. It includes roundtables, forums and workshops in Melbourne and Delhi, Sydney and Ahmedabad, and Brisbane and Bangalore. To support partnerships, a code of practice for creative collaborations is being developed.

Come join in a public forum to consider the opportunities for craft and design through international partnerships. Hear from leading innovative designers and craftspersons in Australia and India, including Trent Jansen, Ishan Khosla, Matthew Butler and Sandra Bowkett. Consider the role of ethical consumerism in generating opportunities in craft, fashion, design and social justice.